Wales 0 England 2: In Defence of the Championship

Anticipation. Excitement. Demoralising disappointment. Eventually, resigned acceptance. Not just the emotions of Welsh football supporters on a thoroughly miserable afternoon at the Millennium Stadium, but the feelings of one supporter of a Championship club upon watching events unfold in the principality. Premier League fans queued up to pour scorn on the Wales performance and Championship players were widely criticised.

The Welsh lineup read much like a Championship representative side, with star second-tier performers such as Swansea City’s Ashley Williams, Norwich City’s Andrew Crofts and Leicester City’s Andy King all included. Add arguably the best right-back in the division, Nottingham Forest’s Chris Gunter, one of its most impressive forwards, Millwall’s Steve Morison, and Cardiff City’s loan star Craig Bellamy, and there was a vague sense that this was a game between the Premier League and the Championship.

Wales were overwhelmed, with the likes of Ashley Young, Scott Parker and Jack Wilshere all far too accomplished for their less-heralded opponents. All in all, the game rammed home the true chasm between the top flight’s elite and the best players in the division below. This will not be news to many people, but we make heroes of these men. Williams, in particular, often looks a tremendous player for Swansea, but he looked light years away from his usual reliable standard in a first half that exposed the Welsh lack of top-level experience.

So how do you defend the Championship’s best against those who will write off their quality after watching such a high-profile game? Many detractors quickly pointed out that not enough Welsh players were drawn from the Premier League. By its very nature, we all know that you will find very few players of the highest quality in the Championship. But it is still interesting to identify the cream of the crop at any level.

There are definite trends. Last season, the goalscoring midfielder was king – all three promoted sides had one: Kevin Nolan of Newcastle United, Graham Dorrans of West Bromwich Albion and the now ubiquitous Charlie Adam of Blackpool. This season, it is the physical, hard-working centre-forward: Morison has 13 goals, while Grant Holt and Luciano Becchio both have 16 and Danny Graham has five more than anyone else with 23. Mercurial talents also account for a number of the spots in the Championship’s top scorers chart – Scott Sinclair, Jay Bothroyd, Max Gradel and, of course, Adel Taarabt.

The best thing about this list? It will be completely different next season. The Premier League’s top goalscorers? Dimitar Berbatov and Carlos Tevez. Yawn. There will be other names there in the next campaign, but the clubs will be the same and the crushing inevitability of the teams at the top will be the same. With the Championship, there’s no telling which teams will make up the top six next season. Even this season, with just eight games remaining, that play-off picture is far from secure.

The most effective way of enthusing about the Championship is to live in glorious isolated denial. At least it is a far cry from the bone-thuddingly dull arguments about whether the Premier League is better than La Liga or the continuing decline of Fernando Torres. You may be able to read about those in one or two other places.

Who cares if there are better players in the division above? Could any of them manage a better solo goal than Scott Sinclair scored against Nottingham Forest last weekend? Do any of them inspire more hero worship than Grant Holt gleans from the Carrow Road faithful? No. They’re just better players at more popular clubs. It is the same in League One and League Two. Watching Peterborough United and Chesterfield recently proved that point. George Boyd is brilliant. Jack Lester is illustrious.

It is understandable that international level takes no prisoners and that Championship players will often come up short. One day soon, though, one or two will get there and watching them along the way is a brilliant experience. Charlie Adam is perhaps the best current example of that glorious progression from Championship talent to widely-admired top flight performer. And don’t forget it’s that time of year again. The play-off system will soon ignite even the most Premier League-focused fans in the country to become interested in the second tier.

Arrive early. Eight games left. So many exciting players to watch. The Championship Select XI may have succumbed to defeat at the hands of the big, bad Premier League yesterday, but the real fun down here is just beginning. Time to get involved.

The Seventy Two
The Seventy Two published an outstanding series of articles about the Football League between 2010-12 and was the brainchild of Leicester City fan, David Bevan. As well as collaborating with The Two Unfortunates on the Football League Blog Network and a mammoth 2011-12 season preview, the site featured a host of leading bloggers and David was rewarded with a nomination in the 2011 Football Supporters’ Federation awards. Latterly, he was joined as co-editor by Joe Harrison and TTU is happy to present this archive of the site’s output.


  1. Mirko Bolesan
    March 29, 2011

    “All in all, the game rammed home the true chasm between the top flight’s elite and the best players in the division below.”

    I’m not so sure it did. Saturday’s game merely showed just how poor Wales are (and have been for some time). It’s also interesting to note that the two mistakes that gifted England’s goals were made by James Collins (Aston Villa) and Danny Collins (Stoke City).

    You can bill the game on Saturday as a Premier League side at a Championship side, but look through the FA Cup results of these sorts of fixtures, I expect you’ll find that the Champ sides normally put up a decent fight against Prem opposition – even if ultimately, they eventually succumb.

    • theseventytwo
      March 29, 2011

      It did cross my mind that the two Collins(‘s? es? seses?) made the crucial mistakes. When I say “best players” I’m talking specifically about Williams, Crofts and King who all looked out of their depth against top Premier League opposition.

      The FA Cup thought did occur to me too, but Wales didn’t get started and only became an attacking force in any way after an hour so it’s a difficult comparison to make.

  2. Joe Harrison
    March 29, 2011

    Also worth keeping in mind it was some of the better Championship players against a number of the best players in the Premier League, arguably not truly representative of the division. For example, in the midfield where King and Crofts proved, unsurprisingly, second best, they were up against players like Lampard and Wilshere – not simply Premier League players but Champions’ League regulars. Should Norwich/Leicester/Swansea go up the issue isn’t going to be whether Crofts/King/Williams are up to the standard of Chelsea, Man United and Arsenal players but rather if they match up to their opposite numbers at Fulham, Wigan, Blackburn etc. If you think of it in this way I think the ‘gulf in class’ so often talked about is a lot smaller than given credit for. The gap between the top of the Championship and the bottom of the Premier League is not that big, the gap between the Premier League’s top 6 and the rest is arguably a lot greater.

    • theseventytwo
      March 29, 2011

      Definitely – couldn’t agree more. I was careful to say the Premier League’s elite. From around 7th? downwards, it’s all up for grabs. Not a huge gulf at all these days.

      • Joe Harrison
        March 29, 2011

        I think the gulf, or rather the lack of one, is what Blackpool actually best display. I know they’re collapsing a bit now but having done so relatively well if you strip away the ‘fairytale’ elements, press hilarity at Holloway etc, the basic fact is that attacking and innovative tactics and management have made a team capable of staying in the Premier League with a squad arguably weaker than any of the Championship’s current top 6.


Leave a Reply to Mirko Bolesan

Cancel Reply