title=An FA Cup Third Round prediction competition

There are 25 FA Cup Third Round ties this weekend involving Football League clubs playing against teams from a different division.

But where will the upsets be found?

There are no prizes, it’s just for fun, but have a look at the fixtures listed below and pick FIVE teams from those in bold who you think may spring a surprise.

There are different numbers of points awarded for how difficult each club’s tie is, ranging from the most difficult (Peterborough away at Fulham, Charlton away at Tottenham and Notts County away at Sunderland - 16 points up for grabs) to the easiest (Torquay United at home to Carlisle United - 2 points available).

Points will be halved in the case of draws.

This points system has been devised based on the division a club is in, the division their opponents are in and whether the tie is home or away.

Please add your teams to the Comments section of this article. Comments from new users require approval so please do not post your comment more than once.

The winner is the person with the biggest number of points for correct predictions.


Full list of fixtures:

Arsenal v Leeds United - Result: 6 points

Blackburn Rovers v QPR - Result: 0 points

Brighton and Hove Albion v Portsmouth - Result: 4 points

Bristol City v Sheffield Wednesday - Result: 8 points

Burnley v Port Vale - Result: 0 points

Burton Albion v Middlesbrough - Result: 6 points

Chelsea v Ipswich Town - Result: 0 points

Doncaster Rovers v Wolverhampton Wanderers - Result: 3 points

Fulham v Peterborough United - Result: 0 points

Hull City v Wigan Athletic - Result: 0 points

Leicester City v Manchester City - Result: 3 points

Millwall v Birmingham City - Result: 0 points

Norwich City v Leyton Orient - Result: 8 points

Reading v West Bromwich Albion - Result: 6 points

Scunthorpe United v Everton - Result: 0 points

Sheffield United v Aston Villa - Result: 0 points

Southampton v Blackpool - Result: 8 points

Stevenage v Newcastle United - Result: 10 points

Stoke City v Cardiff City - Result: 6 points

Sunderland v Notts County - Result: 16 points

Swansea City v Colchester United - Result: 0 points

Torquay United v Carlisle United - Result: 2 points

Tottenham Hotspur v Charlton Athletic - Result: 0 points

Watford v Hartlepool United - Result: 0 points

West Ham United v Barnsley - Result: 0 points


The Seventy Two published an outstanding series of articles about the Football League between 2010-12 and was the brainchild of Leicester City fan, David Bevan. As well as collaborating with The Two Unfortunates on the Football League Blog Network and a mammoth 2011-12 season preview, the site featured a host of leading bloggers and David was rewarded with a nomination in the 2011 Football Supporters’ Federation awards. Latterly, he was joined as co-editor by Joe Harrison and TTU is happy to present this archive of the site’s output.

38 Comments on "An FA Cup Third Round prediction competition"

  1. QPR, Brighton, Reading, Millwall, Southampton.

    Good idea, this. Nice one.

  2. James Dixon says:

    Cardiff - 12 points
    Southampton - 8 points
    Reading - 6 points
    Millwall - 6 points
    Hull - 6 points

  3. epouvantail says:

    Port Vale, Donny, Southampton, Colchester and (much to my own chagrin) Torquay - it’s almost a banker.

  4. Ben Bedford says:

    QPR
    Sheffield United
    Barnsley
    Reading
    Hull

  5. urzz1871 says:

    QPR
    Brighton and Hove Albion
    Doncaster Rovers
    Millwall
    Barnsley

  6. Lily says:

    QPR
    Brighton & Hove
    Donny
    Barnsley
    Southampton

  7. lincoln daniel says:

    Reading, Doncaster Rover, Sheffield
    Wednesday, QPR, Cardiff City.

  8. Matt C. says:

    Brighton, Cardiff, Barnsley, Leyton Orient, Reading.

    Close to taking Peterborough, though.

  9. Lloyd says:

    Come on, David. Give us your predictions as well!

    QPR, Port Vale, Millwall, Reading (I’ll be at the game) and Leeds United.

    • theseventytwo says:

      I’m giving it careful consideration!!

      Cheers Lloyd, loved that Argyle comeback the other night after you logged off at 2-0 down after about 15 minutes!

  10. Rob Hartnett says:

    Not sure there will be many upsets and sadly cannot see QPR doing it but nothing like a free competition…
    Millwall, Brighton, Southampton, Sheffield Wednesday, Reading

    • theseventytwo says:

      Cheers Rob, hope you enjoyed the Warnock calendar!

      Happy New Year!

      • Rob Hartnett says:

        Shame you didn’t hold off until this weekend and the ‘sewer rat’ comments. Surely the binoculars to the official would have been December though the water bottle was pretty good as well. Hopefully it will be very calm now to the end of the season. Pretty chuffed to get four right here!!

  11. Damon says:

    Notoriously awful at predictions but I’d go for:

    Brighton
    Ipswich
    Doncater
    Millwall
    Barnsley

  12. Duncan says:

    cool, I’m up for this sort of thing.

    I’ll go with:
    Brighton
    Sheffield Wednesday
    Barnsley,
    Southampton,
    Notts County.

    aplogies ahead of time to fans of those teams.

  13. JamieCutteridge says:

    Sheffield United, Barnsley, Southampton, Cardiff, Millwall

  14. Ethan says:

    I predict a riot.

  15. Jim says:

    QPR
    Brighton
    Doncaster
    Southampton
    Barnsley

  16. Hmmm, let me see……
    Southampton
    Torquay
    Reading
    Hull City
    Peterborough

  17. theseventytwo says:

    GUEST PREDICTION VIA TWITTER:

    Kevin Davies (Bolton Wanderers) picks:

    Hull City
    Sheffield United
    Scunthorpe United
    Stevenage
    Preston North End - who, of course, are playing another Championship team, but we’ll let him off…

  18. Neil Sherwin says:

    Sheffield Wednesday
    Sheffield United
    Southampton
    Barnsley
    QPR

  19. Duncan says:

    Now that Kevin Davies is involved, can we get a wild card option of York beating Bolton? I’d take them for 20 points.

  20. Joel Murray says:

    QPR
    Sheffield Wednesday
    Doncaster Rovers
    Barnsley
    Cardiff City

    Great stuff!

  21. ke4no says:

    QPR
    Reading
    Sheffield United
    Torquay United
    Barnsley

  22. theseventytwo says:

    Another one via Twitter from @davesargent

    Brighton, Burnley (assume he means Port Vale), Reading, Southampton, Barnsley

  23. Tom H says:

    QPR
    Leicester
    Cardiff
    Hull
    Brighton

  24. QPR -12
    BHA - 4
    Burton A - 6
    Donny - 6
    Barnsley -12

  25. Ansgar says:

    Doncaster
    Reading
    Charlton
    Barnsley
    Hull

  26. Linhem says:

    QPR, Reading, Barnsley, Southampton & P’Boro.

    Having a contest on our own at - http://hyllman.fotbollskanalen.se/2011/01/07/cup-magic/ (Swedish site)

    Not trying to lure people away just appreciating your competition even though i think Boro’s being underestimated.

    • theseventytwo says:

      No problem! Glad you like the idea.

      I am very grateful for all the traffic you send my way from Scandinavia :-)

      • Linhem says:

        Hehe, i shouldn’t take credit for the idea as it is my “boss” whom came up with it, with boss i mean it’s his blog, i only contribute weekly about The Football League.

        But splendid idea and i often recommend your site.

  27. John Verrall says:

    Great idea… I’ll go for:

    Posh (because I’ve got to!)
    Hull
    Millwall
    Brighton
    Doncaster

  28. Michael says:

    QPR - 12 points
    Brighton - 4
    Reading - 6
    Southampton - 8
    Sheff Utd - 6

  29. unitedite says:

    QPR, Cardiff, Doncaster, Brighton , Southampton

    Definitely not the Blades!

  30. theseventytwo says:

    Right, mine are:

    Leeds
    Peterborough
    Port Vale
    QPR
    Sheffield United

Got something to say? Fill your boots.